The trouble with LHINs Part II – How do you integrate half a system?

One of the key problems with the Local Health Integration Networks was evident from the start: they were given responsibility to better integrate our health system, but couldn’t address key parts of that system.

How do you integrate health care without the ability to better coordinate primary care? Physicians have always remained outside of system planning, and it could be argued that much of our system is defined by the agreement between the Ontario Medical Association and the Ministry of Health. This is totally outside the LHINs.

Oddly, while Family Health Teams remain outside the LHINs, Community Health Centres are in.

OPSEU has argued for years that the health system would be more efficient and cost-effective if hospital medical labs also conducted community-based work. Funding for community-based volumes would allow hospitals to increase staffing in their labs, expand scope of testing, and assist in the purchase of new equipment. For community doctors, it would result in faster turnaround of medical laboratory testing and give local physicians a direct lab contact in the community. In a comparison with some of the smallest hospital labs in the province, consultants RPO discovered that these labs were performing the same testing at two-thirds the cost of private labs. Once the hospital loses community-based work (there are only a handful left that still perform community-based testing) it is totally out of the jurisdiction of the LHINs. The North Simcoe Muskoka LHIN washed its hands of this issue when we raised it at the time Bracebridge and Huntsville hospital labs were losing their community volumes.

In Owen Sound the hospital is attempting to divest speech language therapy for preschoolers to the health unit. Once it is gone, the LHIN will no longer be able to address that service given health units are out of its jurisdiction. Who will monitor outcomes once that service is transferred? What happens if it turns out the hospital was the better host for the service, or perhaps another community-based agency? Who hold the health unit to account?

Within the LHIN jurisdiction, integrations are often about moving services around rather than facilitating strong links between health providers.

Integration shouldn’t just be about moving services from provider A to provider B and C.

As the Central East LHIN recently recognized, two addictions services don’t need to merge in order to cooperate on strategic goal setting. While it has been orthodoxy to move services out of hospital, the LHIN recognized the role of Lakeridge Health in maintaining one of these two addiction services.

The LHINs have consistently drawn a line between hospitals and community-based agencies, but hospitals do exist within communities. If a hospital is to provide community-based services, would it not by its very nature integrate well with other in-hospital services?

What role does prevention play? Not only is health promotion outside the jurisdiction of the LHINs, it is completely outside the Ministry of Health and Long Term Care.

We know, for example, that a more active population would dramatically reduce diabetes costs. One estimate suggests that if we were to bring diabetes down to the same level of northern European countries Canada could save $6 billion a year in health costs.

It’s true the LHINs do have contact with health providers outside their jurisdiction. But it has no ability to evaluate the quality of the work done by these providers, or whether the services they provide might be better delivered somewhere else. Nor does a friendly contact necessarily compel these providers to work more closely with hospitals, mental health agencies, home care or long term care homes.

The idea behind the LHINs was to make our health system just that – a system.

Some say five years is not long enough to get the job done. But what significant changes have the LHINs really made to date?

How long will it take to see a system emerge from the disparate entities that presently deliver public healthcare?

Are we expecting too much from bodies appointed to manage when what we really need are signs of bold leadership? Is this even possible within a LHIN model?

And where does the accountability lie? At present everything leads to the Minister of Health. Should it not also lead back to the communities?

Everybody has a shopping list of how we could do better. While our system is in the middle of the pack with regards to cost, there is no question that we could do better from an organizational point of view.

Our LHIN discussion series continues.

2 responses to “The trouble with LHINs Part II – How do you integrate half a system?

  1. You state that there is no health promiton in the MOHLTC. CHC`s across the province are funded by the Ministry of Health and all have a strong health promotion compnent as part of their mandate.
    We are a small CHC in NWO and have 14 full time staff, one of which is a full time Health Promoter. It is imporatnat to be aware of this fact , as CHC`s work is clearly not known or understood. Indeed the LHIN still has a lot to learn about how the Family Health Team model of care differs from the CHC one. They are both multidisciplinary, but the CHC model is driven by community engagement and the social determinants of health.

  2. The CHCs are a fantastic example of health promotion — you are absolutely correct. In fact, many CHCs do run diabetes programs. However, the activities of the Ministry of Health Promotion have little to do with the LHINs. How can we leave that out of the equation? What kind of structure would better reflect a more upstream approach to health promotion?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s